Huge fall in value of Dundee Council no change revenue allocation

Councillor Kevin Keenan
Huge fall in value of Dundee Council no change revenue allocation
30 December 2011
While Dundee City Council’s revenue allocations
from the Scottish Government in each of the next three years remain
virtually the same , in real terms , they mean significant reductions.
The current allocation to Dundee City Council
for 2011-12 has been £317 million.
The future allocations are ( in £ millions)
2012-13 £316 million
2013-14 £318.04 million
2014-15 £318.22 million
Below are these allocations expressed in real
terms at 2011-12 prices, (using Treasury Gross Domestic Product deflators ).
These are shown in bold brackets for each allocation
2011-12 £317 million (£317 million )
2012-13 £316 million (£308 million.)
2013-14 £318 million ( £302 million.)
2014-15 £318 million ( £294 million.)


Commenting on the figures, Councillor Kevin Keenan, Labour group leader on Dundee City Council , said :
"These figures show how unfairly councils have been treated by the Scottish Government to pay for its 5-year council tax freeze that it has never fully funded.
"The Scottish Government is demanding the impossible from councils.
"It orders councils to maintain vital public services, while slashing their budgets with deep cuts at the same time.
" For its loyal council supporters to suggest otherwise is to misrepresent the position of councils that, through no fault of their own, have been forced to carry out cuts to their important services."

Kevin Keenan : Dundee long-term unemployed - largest annual rise of the 4 main Scottish cities

Kevin Keenan
Dundee long-term unemployed - largest annual rise of the 4 main Scottish cities

22 December 2011
Dundee has experienced the greatest increase in the number of long-term unemployed of the 4 main cities of Scotland in the past year.
The TUC survey "Christmas on the Dole 2011" shows that the number of those out of work for one year has increased in Dundee by 490 between November 2010 and November 2011.
The corresponding rise for Glasgow was 395, for Edinburgh 345, and for Aberdeen 215.
In November 2010 there were 595 people out for work in Dundee for one year.
By last month, the figure had risen to 1,085, an 82 per cent increase.
The increases for the other three main cities were less.
For Glasgow it was 7 per cent, for Edinburgh 21 per cent, and for Aberdeen 72 per cent.
Commenting on the Dundee figures, Councillor Kevin Keenan, Labour group leader on Dundee City Council, said,
"This rise in the number of long-term unemployed and the overall number of long-term unemployed are damaging both for Dundee as a city and for the individuals who are personally affected .
"It’s time for decisive action to reduce the jobless total and paid for by popular proposals such as Labour’s £2billion tax on bankers’ bonuses.
"More people of the dole is not the way to restore the economy .
"What we need are more jobs and more people in work paying taxes."

Richard McCready : Congratulations to Johann and Anas

Richard McCready
Congratulations to Johann Lamont and Anas Sarwar
22 December 2011

I would like to congratulate Johann Lamont and Anas Sarwar on their elections as leader and deputy leader of the Scottish Labour Party.
I am particularly pleased as I supported Johann and Anas as did Dundee West Constituency Labour Party.
However, I would also say that I think that the contest has been good for the party.
I think that all of the candidates have had something to offer.
It seems that Johann doesn't need this advice as she has included the leadership contenders in her team, but each of them had interesting things to say about how Labour got into the position which it is in and more importantly how we can get out of this position.
It is clear that Labour needs to change and needs to listen to the message people gave us in May this year.
I was delighted that Johann has spoken of the need for Labour to be the party of all of Scotland.
We must aim to win back both Dundee City West and Dundee City East, and if we want to form the government of Scotland we will have to.
I am also clear that Scottish Labour should have the policies which appeal to the people of Dundee and we need to work on this.
I would offer as a starter that we should focus on fairness or social justice.
Social justice is what Labour should be about.
We should respect our opponents but also be clear that changing the flag flying over us will make no difference to the lives of the Scots we seek to serve.
We should have as our priority making Scotland a fairer country in a fairer world.
We should not get involved in a bidding war on policies; we should stick with what we think is right and argue for fairness and social justice.
I am also pleased to see Johann's Shadow Cabinet team emerging and I am delighted that my friend and colleague Jenny Marra has been given a job as the Community Safety and Legal Affairs spokesperson.
I would also like to thank Iain Gray for his service as Labour's leader.
Clearly Iain's time as leader didn't end as he (or I) would have hoped but there is no doubt that he worked incredibly hard in that role.
He was very supportive of me as the candidate in Dundee City West and I will always be grateful for that.
I am sure that Iain will have much to offer Scottish public life in the future.

Jim McGovern recognised by Dundee Remploy

Jim McGovern recognised by Dundee Remploy
20 December 2011
Jim McGovern, MP for Dundee West, has met with representatives of the Dundee Remploy factory in Dundee who recognised the MP for his long standing support for the local factory.
The Remploy staff also took the opportunity to pass on Mr McGovern a baton celebrating the International Day of the Disabled, which took place earlier this month, which Mr McGovern will pass on in order to recognise the hard work and dedication put in by Remploy’s disabled and able bodied workers.
Jim McGovern said;
"I am humbled that representatives of the management and trade unions at the Dundee Remploy factory came to thank me for my efforts to protect Remploy from government cuts and changes.
"I have always enjoyed working with Remploy’s many dedicated members of staff to ensure their voice is heard at all levels of government.
"I was also honoured to have this baton handed to me, recognising the hard work and dedication of disabled and able-bodied people at Remploy and across the country in their communities and workplaces.
"I will be passing this baton on in recognition of their efforts."
Mr McGovern concluded,
"There is a lot of work yet to do in order to see Remploy’s future is secure.
"The consultation to the Sayce Review ended last month, and I participated in a Westminster Hall debate last Wednesday in an effort to ensure that the government does not remove their support for this important company.
"I will continue to stand up for Remploy into the future."

Marlyn Glen : Dundee in 2015

Marlyn Glen
Dundee in 2015
16 December 2011
Last month I took part in what was one of the most memorable events in the story of the Labour Movement in Dundee – the 8,000 demonstration against Tory Government attacks on decent retirement pensions for public sector workers.
It was a feat of organisation, a procession of people power with hundreds and hundreds of brightly coloured flags and vivid banners, and expressions of unity as a light to guide us down the long grim tunnel that this decade will be.
By contrast, the Tory Government’s attempts to portray their deficit reduction policy as a crusade of national solidarity – "We’re all in this together" - were rudely dispelled last week when David Cameron pleaded with the rest of the EU for special treatment for just one group in Britain – the banks, the same institutions that have got the country into the mess we’re in.
The other 26 countries in the EU, some with governments that are on the Centre-Right of politics want to impose a Robin Hood-style tax on banks’ transactions.
However, David Cameron stood firm for Bankers’ Rights, for the same institutions still revelling in bonuses, that will not lend today to businesses that want to borrow money to create jobs.
In the 2010's Dundee faces a "lost decade" in which its "lost generation" will see its living standards slump to levels not experienced in many years.
Employment in Scotland is forecast not to return to previous higher levels until the early 2020s.
A couple living on average wages in 2015 will be no better off than they were in 2002.
So a couple in Dundee with a joint weekly income of £714 this year will be worse off in 2015 than the same couple in Dundee were in 2002 with a joint income then of £599 .
Male pay in Dundee has slumped by 7 per cent on average in the past year.
A pay freeze will endure in the public sector till 2013, and Chancellor George Osborne plans to limit pay rises to 1 per cent till 2015 thereafter.
As prices rise, real wages fall, reducing living standards.
The new economic model is the old belief that government should be acting in the same manner as the household does.
This says that when a household hits hard times, it cuts back , and therefore a government in the same straits should cut its spending and as quickly as possible.
Decades ago, this argument was disproved by Keynes with his "paradox of thrift".
For Keynes, national economies cannot be run like individual household budgets.
The more money a person saves or cuts back on, the less money is available for buying the goods and services that are being produced, leading to job losses and less taxation coming into Treasury.
The next few years are almost certain to be less healthier times.
Not surprisingly, personal health worsens as insecurity heightens.
One of the best ways of keeping people healthy is to keep them in a job.
Job loss and job insecurity can make people more vulnerable to illness through loss of self-worth, lower income, exclusion from previous social activities because of lower incomes, and living with no control over daily life.
The Child Growth Foundation has already expressed concerns that huge job cuts mean less income, resulting in people turning to cheaper calorie-rich food higher in fat, risking higher levels of diabetes and obesity.
Cuts in voluntary sector funding puts greater stress on an already overstretched NHS, at a time when the number of nursing and midwifery staff in NHS Tayside has fallen to its lowest in 4 years.
Local government faces a cut of some £700 million in real terms till 2015.
Councils have received a "flat cash freeze" in their revenue allocation from the Scottish Government as a result.
These dire assessments describe how everyday life will be in the first few years of this decade .
The 30th. November rallies across Britain against pensions "reform" are unlikely to be the last.
Pensions are very much a personal rather than a political issue.
Bear this comparison in mind …. last weekend, world-wide publicity was given to Moscow, ( population 11 million, the most populous city in Europe), saw 60,000 demonstrators take to the streets last week in protests against election-rigging by Vladimir Putin.
In Dundee, (population 140,000,) the strength of opposition to Tory plans to cut public sector pensions saw over 8,000 take to the streets.

Dundee 2015 figures
Pay
The Institute for Fiscal Studies predicts that a couple living on average wages in 2015 will be no better off than they were in 2002
In 2002, the median weekly pay for men in Dundee was £358.
In 2011 it now stands at £ 405 .
In 2002 the median weekly pay for women in Dundee was £241 .
In 2011 it stands at £309 .
(Source : Office of National Statistics )
So a couple in Dundee with a joint weekly income of £714 this year will be worse off in 2015 than the same couple in Dundee were in 2002 with a joint income then of £599 .
Dundee City Council spending – the Flat Cash Freeze
Dundee City Council’s revenue allocations from the SNP Government to provide services in the city remain frozen, meaning a cut in real terms spending and services.
2011-12 £317million
2012-13 £316milllion
2013-14 £318million
2014-15 £318 million
The number of teachers in Dundee is now the lowest in 6 years.
NHS Tayside spending
NHS Tayside’s current budget of £596milllion is forecast to increase in real terms by just £6million by 2015, a 1 per cent increase, at a time when health service costs are rising annually by 4 per cent.
Overall in Scotland total health sending is set to decrease by £319million in real terms.
The number of nursing and midwifery staff in NHS Tayside is now the lowest in 4 years.
Fuel Poverty
1 in 4 households in Scotland lives in fuel poverty.
A household is defined as being in fuel poverty if, in order to maintain a satisfactory heating regime, it would be required to spend more than 10% of its income on fuel.
This year, as energy companies pushed up prices even higher, the SNP Government all but abandoned its promise to "eradicate" fuel poverty in Scotland by 2016.
The SNP Government has also slashed funding for fuel poverty support by one third – from £71 million last year to £48 million this year.
Obesity
Over 1 in 4 of all adults in Scotland is obese, with the highest level, almost 40 per cent in the age group 55-64 .
The percentage of children aged 2-15 with a body mass index "outwith the healthy range" rose to its highest level last year to over 30 per cent.
Diabetes
NHS Tayside over 19,000 diagnosed with diabetes at the beginning of 2011 almost 1 in 20 of the population.
Almost ten years previously the figure had been 11,200.

Dundee Unemployment : Neither Plan Osborne nor Plan Salmond has worked

Dundee Unemployment : Neither Plan Osborne nor Plan Salmond has worked
Councillor Kevin Keenan
16 December 2011
Unemployment in Dundee rose last month to 5,284 , representing an unemployment rate of 5.6 per cent.
Dundee’s unemployment rate continues to be higher than both the Scottish and the UK averages ( 4.0 and 3.8 per cent respectively)
Commenting on the Dundee figures, Councillor Kevin Keenan, Labour group leader on Dundee City Council , said,
" In September, when unemployment in Scotland was lower than in the rest of the UK, Alex Salmond claimed the credit for this, and then invited Tory Chancellor George Osborne to follow SNP policies on the economy so as to bring unemployment down in the rest of the UK.
"However, now the situation has reversed. The unemployment rate in Scotland is now higher than in the rest of the UK.
"Alex Salmond keeps silent about this, refusing to accept that by his own argument, his policies must now be responsible for higher unemployment in Scotland.
"Alex Salmond can't have his cake and eat it.
"The truth is, as far as Dundee is concerned, neither George Osborne’s plan nor Alex Salmond’s plan has worked for Dundee.
"Dundonians know from their own grim experience that the Tory Government’s polices are not designed for their city.
"As for Alex Salmond, last month was the 54th. month that Alex Salmond has been First Minister of Scotland.
"In each and every single month during his time as First Minister, unemployment in Dundee has always remained above the Scottish average.
"Labour believes that its own 5 point plan is the best way to restore the economy in the immediate term and get more jobs through

* a tax on bankers' bonuses to pay for jobs for the young

* accelerating long-term investment projects

* a temporary reversal of January's 5 per cent increase in VAT

* a 1 per cent cut in VAT home improvements, repairs and maintenance to 5%

* a national insurance tax break for a year for all those small firms which take on extra workers
"I am supporting the call from Jenny Marra MSP that there should now be a Jobs Summit for Dundee."

Jim McGovern calls on UK and Scottish Governments to act on unemployment

Jim McGovern calls on UK and Scottish Governments to act on unemployment
14 December 2011
Jim McGovern, MP for Dundee West, has called on the UK and Scottish governments to act on rising unemployment in Dundee.
Official statistics released today show that in November 2011 there were 285 more Job Seekers Allowance (JSA) claimants in Dundee West compared to November 2010, and 48 more claimants compared to October 2011.
Jim McGovern said,
"It is unacceptable that unemployment is rising in Dundee. It is clear that the private sector is not growing, and public sector cuts are only making that worse.
"We need to see a plan from the Tory-led government in London and the SNP executive in Edinburgh that gets the economy growing.
"All they currently have is faith in a miracle recovery in the private sector, which simply isn’t happening. They need to take action to increase investment and create jobs.
"The SNP need to stop conspiring on separation and direct their attention on growing the economy.
"We cannot have industries pulling out of the city when we need more, not less, jobs. Uncertainty about Scotland’s future is damaging our efforts.
Mr McGovern concluded,
"Dundee has a great deal of potential, but it is suffering from a lack of leadership.
"A comprehensive plan for growth must be the top priority; not ideological public sector cuts or hugely damaging plotting around separation."

Jenny Marra MSP welcomes SFA Football Academy at St John's

Jenny Marra MSP welcomes SFA Football Academy at St John's
15 December 2011
Jenny Marra has today welcomed the news that St John’s High School is to be earmarked as one of the SFA’s seven ‘performance schools’ to be created across Scotland.
The existing programme, which gives up and coming youngsters the opportunity to access top level coaching before and after the school day, is to be taken over by the SFA and will form an integral part of the Association’s plan to develop talent of the future.
Jenny has spearheaded the campaign to bring the proposed National Football Academy to her home city and this recent announcement can only strengthen Dundee’s case as being a centre of footballing excellence.
Jenny said,
"I think this is great news.
"There is a lot of good work in sport and football that is already going on at St John’s.
"I visited the school a couple of weeks ago and was very impressed.
"It will also help our campaign to bring the National Football Academy to Dundee.
"It would be an elite performance centre for people from across the country.
"Having another performance academy adds to the strength of the bid the council has agreed to put forward.
"I will continue to campaign on this issue and hopefully we can see the future of football in Dundee."

Councillor Laurie Bidwell : Teacher Numbers Tumble in Dundee

Councillor Laurie Bidwell
Teacher Numbers Tumble in Dundee
8 December 2011
The SNP Government’s latest figures indicate that the number of teachers in Dundee is the lowest for 6 years, lower than when the SNP took over the Scottish Government in 2007.
The figures show that the number of primary school teachers in Dundee is now at its lowest level since 2005.
The numbers fell again in the last year to 639 at the census point.
In secondary schools, the number of teachers in Dundee is also at its lowest level since 2005.
The numbers decreased over the last year to 716 at the census point.
The tables showing Pupil/Teacher ratios also show a noticeable increase from 11.7 pupils to 1 teacher in 2009 to 12.1 pupils to 1 teacher in 2011.
Commenting on the figures, Labour's Education Spokesperson in the City, Councillor Laurie Bidwell said,
"In Dundee the Education Convener says she hasn't removed teachers from the classroom but the growth in the number of pupils to each teacher (the Pupil - Teacher ratio) paints a different picture."
"We can't go on reducing the number of teachers in our schools in Dundee without having a negative effect on the attainment and achievement of our pupils.
"Dundee deserves better.
" Having promised the earth four and a half years ago, the SNP Government still refuses to face up to the truth today that they have not reduced average class sizes.
"They, and their SNP controlled Council in Dundee, are responsible for the decline in teacher numbers and an adverse rise in the pupil/teacher ratios in our City.
"The SNP made unprecedented promises about improvements in education, none of which have ever been properly or fully funded."

Marlyn Glen : NHS Tayside - Three Facts and An Admission

Marlyn Glen
7 December 2011
NHS Tayside Staffing : Three Facts and An Admission

Three significant NHS staffing figures were published last month and one highly significant admission was made.
The latest official government figures show that the number of nursing and midwifery staff in NHS Tayside continues to remain below the level it was at when Alex Salmond’s SNP Government took over in 2007.
The overall NHS workforce in NHS Tayside is now over 300 less than it was two years ago .
Around 1 out of 4 student nurses in abandon their courses.

and

Health Secretary Nicola Sturgeon finally admitted that the number of nurses and midwifery staff in the NHS in Scotland is now lower than the number was under Labour.
Let’s look at the first fact.
The latest official government figures show that numbers of nursing and midwifery staff in NHS Tayside continue to fall under Alex Salmond’s SNP Government.
They remain at a level below the number of nursing and midwifery posts in the health board when the SNP came into government in 2007.
It’s now 23 whole–time equivalents in staffing numbers below what the figures were back then.
The headcount figure is also down on the 2007 level.
This trend stacks up poorly against the record of the previous Labour-led Scottish Executive.
In the last 4 years, under Labour from 2002-2006, the number of nursing and midwifery staff in NHS Tayside increased each year , and increased in total by over 230.
Let’s look at the second fact again now.
The overall number of NHS staff in NHS Tayside is now over 300 less than it was two years ago.
Today there are 13,914 staff in the health board, including GPs and dentists, ( using the SNP Government’s preferred choice of headcount figures.)
This is a decrease of almost 320 from the 14,230 staff level reported two years ago.
This trend also stacks up poorly against the record of the previous Labour-led Scottish Executive.
In its last 4 years, under Labour, the overall number of staff in NHS Tayside increased each year and increased in total by around 900.
These figures were already expected because of the SNP Government’s failure to match the Labour-led Scottish Executive’s growth in health spending.
The third fact is that the number of nursing students who drop out of their courses, known as the "attrition rate" still affects around 1 in 4.
The reasons for this are well-known and long-standing and include the need for childcare assistance and better support for clinical placements as well as financial difficulties and problems with career prospects.
This last issue, career prospects, now looks like taking on a greater significance.
In terms of demand, as the population ages there will be more need for nursing staff
In term of supply, there is a need to replace an ageing NHS workforce with younger staff .
Some 10,000 of Scotland’s nursing workforce are now over 55
In addition more of them are needed to meet the rising demand from the elderly.
However, student nurses can now see their career opportunities being restricted as the number of nursing posts in the NHS in Scotland falls - 2,000 lost in the past year, and so these diminishing career prospects will create anxiety, disquiet and perhaps a career re-decision.

And what of the highly significant admission ?

Earlier last month, ( 10th. November ) Nicola Sturgeon finally admitted to the Scottish Parliament, the SNP’s failure on nursing numbers which are now below those under Labour.
She stated,
"The number of nurses and midwives has reduced by 0.2 per cent from the level that we inherited. "
No Government or health secretary can afford to have declining health staff numbers , particularly when you have previously declaimed that you " will protect the health service during the lifetime of this Parliament " with fewer nursing and midwifery staff.
Why is the NHS in this condition ?
The SNP Government simply just pass on cuts from the Tory Government in Westminster.
Furthermore, more money being spent on the SNP’s populist 5-year council tax freeze means of course less money for spending on the health service.
As a consequence of greater and greater duties being demanded with no increase in resources for the NHS in Scotland, several career options for loyal staff such as voluntary redundancy packages have their appeal.
This, however, result in a further loss of nursing skills, with overworked and under-pressure dedicated staff remaining.
The extent of this working environment is revealed in a new poll of its members by the Royal College of Nursing in Scotland where more than 1 in 3 said that there were discouraged or told not to report their concerns over issues such as staffing levels or patient safety.
When RCN Scotland appeared before the Scottish Parliament’s Health and Sport Committee last month, their observation resonated with many :
"Nurses think they are very much on their own and that they are being targeted for savings……Nursing has lost a sense of all being in it together."

Jenny Marra supports Dundee students at Education Rally

Jenny Marra Supports Dundee Students at Education Rally
6 December 2011
Jenny Marra MSP showed her support for Dundee students at a rally held before the public meeting on post-16 education in Tayside attended by Cabinet Secretary for Education Mike Russell.
The students gathered to present their response to the post-16 consultation paper that proposes increased ministerial powers over the governance of further education institutions. Earlier this year the paper sparked controversy in its proposal to give ministers the power to merge institutions.
Speaking before the rally Ms Marra said:
"I am delighted to be here to support the students in presenting their response to the post-16 legislative paper. Both Abertay and Dundee university student associations have been clear in their opposition to any merger proposals, as well as the Government’s cuts to Colleges. It is important their voice is heard throughout this consultation as it is their future at stake."
William Mohieddeen, president of Abertay Students Union added:
"The University of Abertay Students' Association thanks all supporters of the Hands Off Abertay campaign and those that are backing the Tayside students' response in 'All Taygether Now'.
"Particularly we would like to thank Jenny Marra MSP for addressing the students attending the rally at Dundee Union.
"The campaigning has been fully about projecting the student voice to the highest level in Government and we recognise those such as Ms Marra who are keen to interact with students and acknowledge the position they have in partnership in their education.
"This has been a significant piece of student activism and we hope to see significant interaction from the education secretary before imposing any further changes to the higher education sector.

Call for More Full-Time Jobs for Dundee as city is revealed as the lowest in mainland Scotland

Call for More Full-Time Jobs for Dundee as city is revealed as the lowest in mainland Scotland
Councillor Kevin Keenan
2 December 2011
Dundee has the lowest percentage of people in full-time work in the whole of mainland Scotland, according to Government figures from the Office of national Statistics.
The city has just 68.4 per cent of 16-64 year olds in full-time work , 45,300 in full time work out of a workforce of 66,300.
The Scottish average is 73.6.
The figure for Glasgow was 75.8.
Figures for all local council areas show that but for Shetland, with 66 per cent working full-time, Dundee would have had the lowest level of full-time employment in the whole of Scotland.
As a consequence of having the lowest full-time figure, Dundee has the highest percentage of people in part-time work in mainland Scotland.
Commenting on the figures, Councillor Kevin Keenan, Labour Group leader on Dundee City Council, said,
"Each and every Member of the Labour Team here in Dundee will work with every business and economic development agency, along with both the Governments of Westminister and Holyrood to see jobs delivered for our city, the City of Dundee.
"Good jobs will bring with them the much needed security to Dundee and its people.
"This is something that most of us are crying out for as we make our way through these very challenging economic times.
"Dundee people have a lot to offer the manufacturing industry and the City needs manufacturing.
"It’s therefore vital that we attract the much promised jobs from within the growing renewable wind and wave electricity energy production and supply industry.
"Manufacturing industry is acknowledged to be the best source of full-time employment.
"It’s imperative that this City gets more jobs, particularly full- time jobs.
"Full-time jobs tend to have greater security, better wage rates and delivers more chance of an occupational pension scheme."
"Part-time jobs tend to be much more casual with lower wage rates and little prospect of a pension."

Jim McGovern condemns Chancellor's Autumn statement

Jim McGovern condemns Chancellor's Autumn statement

29 November 2011

Jim McGovern, MP for Dundee West, condemned the Autumn Statement given by the Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne.

The Autumn Statement comes as the OECD warns of renewed threat of recession for the UK economy, the Office of Budget Responsibility further downgraded the UK’s short term growth expectations, and youth unemployment reaches an all time high of one million young people currently out of work.

Jim McGovern said,

"As the economy stagnates, and the OECD warns we may fall back into recession, and unemployment increases across the country, these announcements are too little too late.

"People in Dundee need to see real action from this government in order to see that jobs and investment increases. That didn’t happen today.

"I support more home building and infrastructure investment, but there should much more of it, and it should have been done over a year ago.

"To cut vital tax credits for hard working families shows that the government are making the most vulnerable and hardest working suffer for their failed economic policies.

"The government’s cuts, and their lack of action, has chocked off economic recovery.

" The government are responsible for much of what has gone wrong. Today George Osborne did not take responsibility for that."

Mr McGovern concluded,

"Government borrowing is up, economic growth is down and unemployment is increasing every day.

"These announcements, many of which are not new, are too little for the people of Dundee.

"The government must come up with a comprehensive plan for economic growth, and they must do so as a matter of urgency."

Jenny Marra MSP : Youth Unemployment

Jenny Marra MSP

Youth Unemployment

Speech in the Scottish Parliament

1 December 2011

I am angry.

I am angry after yesterday's strikes.

I am angry at John Mason?s suggestion that young people in our country do not want to work, and I invite him to come up to Dundee and speak to some of the young people to whom I speak every week, who are desperate to work—the young men who have left school and are desperate to get into the construction industry but cannot because there are no jobs available for them.

I am angry that, since two weeks ago, when the unemployment figures came out, cybernats continually tweet me with their answer to the unemployment figures, which is that young people in this country do not want to work.

That seems to be the message continually coming from members on the Scottish National Party benches and from those who tweet and put things on Facebook in their names.

Those of us who marched and were on the picket lines yesterday recommitted ourselves to fight the scourge of youth unemployment in this country, because yesterday was not just about pensions, although their protection is exceedingly important.

Yesterday was, in essence, about work: people?s right to work, to expect to work, to aspire to work, to enjoy success at work, to be properly paid for work, to be challenged, to pay taxes and to build a financial and satisfying legacy for old age.

The crisis in youth unemployment in Scotland has grown to breaking point.

As the economic downturn has unfolded it has become increasingly clear that Scotland?s youth are being hardest hit in the fight to find work, training or access to further education.

I want to talk a bit about the structural problems of the economic downturn that are affecting the choices of the young people in those of our communities that are most decimated by unemployment, such as an increasingly competitive job market that keeps them shut out, and a further education system that will see fewer opportunities for them after the SNP has made its debilitating cuts to colleges.

In a recent study, Professor David Bell of the University of Stirling talks of a "trade-down" generation, with today?s graduates, who are faced with an increasingly difficult job market, taking on jobs in retail or services at minimum wage—jobs that would otherwise usually have been done by those who had not been to university.

The burden of the economic squeeze has landed on the shoulders of young people who are on the first rung on the employability ladder.

They have left school early without many qualifications or any work experience and have entered a job market where they are now competing for jobs against more highly qualified candidates—and they cannot compete.

Little wonder, then, that unemployment among young people in Scotland is rising at a rate that is double that for 25 to 49-year-olds.

Traditionally, for those who have left school early and want to boost their employability, there has always been the option of studying or training at college, but demand for college places has soared and the Educational Institute of Scotland reports that college courses are increasingly difficult to find.

Coupled with budget cuts of 40 per cent in real terms, which I have put to the cabinet secretary before, and college mergers—with a predicted loss of up to 2,000 places at Angus College alone—the college option is becoming harder and harder for young people to realise, leaving them with little option but to return to school.

The rate of pupils staying on at school past the age of 16 has jumped from a relatively stable rate of between 77 and 79 per cent between 2000 and 2008 to 83 per cent last year—the highest figure on record.

Immense pressure is being put on teachers to provide courses for such large numbers.

The First Minister: Will Jenny Marra acknowledge that among the many recommendations of the Smith group is one that says that staying on at school is a good thing? Might that have something to do with this Government?s determination to maintain educational maintenance allowance, which has been removed elsewhere in these islands?

Jenny Marra: There are many who find the cuts to educational maintenance allowance quite debilitating.

It is good that some people are staying on at school, but it is not acceptable that others are not.

I will read to the chamber something that was posted on Facebook yesterday by the brother of Angus MacLeod.

Labour members feel very strongly that this sums up the state of youth unemployment in our country.

It is about a boy called Liam Aitchison, who died earlier this week.

John MacLeod met him in late September as they waited for a ferry. John was returning from the Uist communion and ended up giving Liam a lift to Stornoway.

He said that Liam was,

"engaging, smart, funny, had quite a back-story, a strong handshake and was eerily old for his years ... he would hail me on the streets of town (usually to tap me for fags)."

Two weeks ago, they met up for lunch.

John took reams of notes to get a CV together for him.

He had a looming date before the sheriff for "some juvenile mischief" and they felt that finding Liam "a situation" or a job might help.

John wrote that Liam

"had ... lost weight in these weeks; looked rather flat and tired. Picked at his food; inexplicably declined pudding. 'I'll Facebook you,' he said; but he didn't".

Liam never touched Facebook or his mobile again.

John wrote: "Liam went missing a few days later. His body was found in a derelict shack by the edge of Stornoway yesterday ... a lad disadvantaged in many ways ... in life ... but who had worked hard in the Pollachar Inn and on four fishing boats, had earned six Standard Grades, was a drummer in Uist pipe band ... and who could play a bewildering range of instruments"—

John said that Liam "completed the John Muir award in 2009 and was a keen cook".

He was not "a ned, a chav, a loser or a statistic".

John described him as "a young man worth meeting".

Liam was a young man who needed a job and who will never now realise that potential.

Liam was 16 years old.

Richard McCready : Reflections on the Day of Action on Pensions

Richard McCready

Reflections on the Day of Actions for Pensions

1 December 2011

On Wednesday I joined thousands of others to march through the streets of Dundee to show my opposition to the changes to many public sector workers pensions.
It was good to see so many people on the demonstration.
It was disappointing that the demonstration was necessary.
Dundee West Constituency Labour Party unanimously made their views known about this issue.
You can see the statement which they supported (link) you can read more about the unions together campaigns here.
I am sure that there were people present yesterday who were taking part in their first demonstration.
It is clear that right across the country people were supporting this campaign.
The Prime Minister described Wednesday as a 'damp squib'.
I beg to differ.
I hope that there is a negotiated settlement which allows all workers dignity in retirement.
I support a fair pension and dignity in retirement for all workers, whether in the public or private sector.
I hope that the Tory-led UK Government and the SNP-led Scottish Government, along with local government recognise that dignity in retirement and a fair pension are important.